Director: Orson Welles
Note: Spoilers for Vertigo below
A downfall of many great directors is, surprisingly, plot. Some directors just can't be all that bothered with it. Hitchcock's plots are often totally preposterous - Chuck Klosterman said of the murder scheme concocted in Vertigo, 'It would've been easier for the [actual killer] to simply kill every man he'd ever met.' I feel this is a problem too with Orson Welles, who fills The Stranger with some phenomenal camera shots, but gets stuck with a second-rate script.
Another complaint I have about old films in general is the use of music, which even to this point had not fully evolved away from silent movie style music. A character might be walking along and the music is blaring, unnecessarily. Regardless, this film contains an Orson Welles speech almost as good as his famously diabolical rant in The Third Man, but I still can't consider this a classic.